joelh

Members
  • Content count

    104
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    2

Everything posted by joelh

  1. joelh

    Door Chimes

    So it may seem minor, but one of the things that is important to us is being able to hear a chime when certain doors are opened. One thing good about Wink is that they have a chime that has like 8 different sounds. That would be a neat upgrade over iris. But I'm concerned about Wink's expand-ability. And apparently Wink's security chops are weak. Dome and Aeon Labs both have a device that is a combination multi-chime/siren that apparently will fit the bill, but requires a device handler on ST and on Vera only has one chime sound available. Anyone have experience with the various platforms under discussion and how they do in this somewhat minor, but important to me, area?
  2. joelh

    Best Contact Sensor for Outdoor use

    OK, status report. So far so good. I have two gen 2 contact sensors and one gen 3(? - the one with the magnetic ball mount) that I've applied this coating to (https://www.amazon.com/dp/B008O9YIV6/ref=cm_sw_em_r_mt_dp_U_DRQGCbCK245A0). All three are preforming nominally, and we'd had several rain storms since I did this. I'll report back if any of them go tango-uniform.
  3. I have Iris V1 contact sensors on two gates outside my house. Even though these are not rated as outdoor devices, they have been rock solid for over 4 years. Anyone have experience with using a ST compatible contact sensor outside? If so which ones? I'm in Northern California, so temp range is question is reasonable (low as 30s and high as 90s, typically). Real issue I think is rain.
  4. joelh

    Best Contact Sensor for Outdoor use

    That's kinda like what I'm doing. Just with stuff that is specifically made for this purpose (link a few posts up). Just arrived today. Rain expected tomorrow, so I'm going to try and do this and get one up to test. You guys will be the first to know how it goes. Really hope it works - don't want to go cutting into my gate or buying a housing.
  5. joelh

    Best Contact Sensor for Outdoor use

    Thanks for the input everyone. Here's my plan... I took apart a 2nd gen(?) ST contact sensor (https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0118RQW3W/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o07_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1) and it's possible to take the board completely out of the housing. After doing that, I'm going to apply this: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B008O9YIV6/ref=cm_sw_em_r_mt_dp_U_DRQGCbCK245A0 to the whole board, making sure to leave the battery contacts bare. Then I'll pop the board back in the housing and put it up. If this works, I'll do the same with a ST motion sensor (also confirmed the board can be removed). I'll post the results...
  6. joelh

    Best Contact Sensor for Outdoor use

    Thanks. Doesn't look like they have a outdoor contact sensor though, which is what I need. I'm intrigued by that 3-way switch though... and price is right. - roughly same as the GE/Jasco switches that I have. Still requires a neutral, but I'm sure at least one box in my 3way chain (have a couple 4 ways as well) has a neutral.
  7. joelh

    Best Contact Sensor for Outdoor use

    Same here, but I've chosen SmartThings. So I have to find another solution. Interesting. Off to research silicone sprays... Do you know what contact sensors does your friend uses? If Iris V1, he really doesn't need the silicone..
  8. joelh

    Best Contact Sensor for Outdoor use

    On fence gates to the back yard. I want open/closed indication, so contact sensor. If I don't find something comparable to the iris V1's (I love those things), then maybe what I'll do is make a mortise in the wooden gate to protect it from the rain. Thanks for the suggestion.
  9. joelh

    SmartThings experience so far

    My experience has been about the same, but I'm a bit behind you in the switchover. I'm a little frustrated with having to navigate the two apps (I find I need to use both to achieve everything I want to do), and the poor (IMO) execution of event history. But that's more than evened out by ActionTiles (just got stated with that), and the customization options (have installed a few Smartapps and DH's using the IDE). Once I get fully transitioned over to ST, I'll go for my WebCoRE badge 😉
  10. joelh

    ST and Event History

    I choose to go with ST, and I'm kinda cool with it, for the most part. It is TERRIBLE with event history, though. On the new app, the History page available from the main menu is worthless. On the "classic" app, each device page has a "Recently" tab that shows events, but it shows WAAAAAY too much (temperature readings, vibration readings, etc in a addition to open/closed/motion/etc). But no single place to see the overall event history like Iris did. Am I missing something?
  11. joelh

    ST and Event History

    Ah, thanks. I didn't realize you could tap on the "Device Messages" and "Device Activity" to call up the filter screen. That said, my Activity listing is mostly empty (even with all the filters turned on). It only (sometimes) lists my phone's coming and going - no history at all from any devices. Could this be a "new app" issue? I'm on iOS if that matters.
  12. joelh

    Alarms and SHM

    My favorite thing about SHM is when an alarm is triggered, it can play the sounds of dogs barking (or several other sounds) through our 7 sonos speakers.
  13. joelh

    Vera Thread - Pro\Con

    They don't. That's why Lowe's is essentially refunding all the V1 stuff through the reception program.
  14. joelh

    Vera Thread - Pro\Con

    These are V1 contact sensors:
  15. joelh

    Vera Thread - Pro\Con

    Sorry but I have to ask - are these V1 or V2/V3 contact sensors that you are not able to pair with Vera?
  16. I think you only get one chance to run the redemption routine. Some make sure ALL of your V1 devices are connected before doing it to maximize your refund. I think I may have a few that I missed, as I didn't realize at the time...
  17. @joshfromvera, what would be very useful for evaluation would be some videos or even just screen shots of various tasks in your app. Without this, we're kind of flying blind until we buy a hub and start playing. I'm not interested in buying hubs until I find the one that's best for me. Some of the things I'm interested in seeing are: 1) viewing and filtering the event log (please tell you you have a "show everything except motion sensors" option!) 2) Process for creating rules, and the options available therein. 3) Viewing temperature and power usage graphs (hoping you have this) 4) I see the Dome and Aeon Labs Siren/Chime device are compatible - I'd like to see how you set a particular chime for a particular door. Also, thanks for being here for these types of questions.
  18. joelh

    Iris is Officially Done

    Hmmm. Interesting. I've started leaning towards Wink. Any insight on that system?
  19. Just about all of my contact and motion sensors are V1 Iris, so I'm going to need to buy a bunch of them for my new hub (prob will be either SmartThings or Hubitat). Looking around on-line there seems to be bunch out there. Anyone have any favorites? Any to stay away from? I like the price of this one: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B06XDJ3KYC/ref=cm_sw_em_r_mt_dp_U_dk2uCbWVEYBJN
  20. Anyone else having trouble getting to this site?
  21. The redemption process is quick and easy. Before you hit Accept it will show you how much they are going to give you for each device that it sees on your system. But best I can tell, you only get to do it once - so make sure everything is there. I was so impressed with the amount they gave me, I just pressed ahead and committed. Fortunately, I don't think I have TOO many V1 devices not connected. That said, I saw somewhere in another thread that someone had connected a V1 device today and it did NOT show up on the list of "redempt-able" devices. So perhaps they took a snapshot of everyone's system and are only going to offer refunds for devices that were on your system before today? Or maybe it takes a while for devices to show up on the "redemptable" list?
  22. joelh

    Iris is Officially Done

    Thanks for the detailed breakdown. Would you say that Hubitat has more upside? With the decline in SmartThings support response, I wonder if it has reached it's peak?
  23. joelh

    Iris is Officially Done

    Wow, I'm getting ~$1300., for about 40 devices. Way more than I would have expected. Now to choose a replacement system....
  24. joelh

    Iris is Officially Done

    I'll take you up on that! I figured those were my two choices. If you were to choose one to transition to, which would it be?
  25. joelh

    Generic Z-Wave Driver

    See this thread: I tried this before the update and it didn't work, then tried it after and it DID work.